Kerryn Boogaard Kerryn Boogaard
Beverly Goldsmith Beverly Goldsmith
Zoe Bingley-Pullin Zoe Bingley-Pullin

No boost from learning with stronger peers:

Students whose inclusion in a gifted & talented education program is marginal do not perform better than they would elsewhere.
By Motherpedia
Date: February 18 2014
Editor Rating:
gifted-children-research

A new study contradicts the popular theory that students perform better when surrounded by higher-achieving classmates.

Michigan State University’s (MSU) Scott Imberman and colleagues found that marginal students in a middle school gifted and talented program – despite learning alongside the “best and brightest” – performed no better on national tests than a similar group of students who didn’t qualify for the program.

“This paper is part of a growing body of literature suggesting that just because you have stronger peers doesn’t necessarily mean you are going to perform better,” said A/Professor Imberman.

Gifted and talented programs have grown in popularity with approximately 400,000 of Australia's 3.6 million 5-18 year-old population enrolled in a gifted and talented program. The NSW Department of Education states that "... about 10% of the Australian population is gifted or significantly advanced in a specific area".

The MSU study, in the American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, provides an important first step in understanding the effects of gifted and talented programs on students.

Using a sample of more than 14,000 fifth-graders in an urban school district, Imberman and his colleagues analysed the students’ standardised test scores in maths, science, reading, social studies and language arts.

The study targeted a group of students who qualified for a gifted and talented program by barely meeting a certain threshold based on past academic performance. Their test scores were compared to the students who just missed meeting the threshold – in other words, students who were very similar academically.

A/Professor Imberman said the marginal students in the gifted and talented program showed no improvement in test scores over the non-qualifying students in any of the five subjects.

The study also looked at gifted and talented students who were picked via a lottery-style ballot for a special program, which emphasises a more intensive, specialised curriculum. The researchers compared test scores of the students who won the lottery to the gifted and talented students who lost the lottery and found no significant difference in four of the five subjects: maths, reading, social studies and language arts. The magnet students did show improvement in science.

Share This Tweet This Email To Friend
Related Articles
active-kids
A new app aimed at incorporating physical activity into everyday…
Read more
learning_-_curriculum
Over the past six years or so, thousands of experts…
Read more
children_spelling
If spelling is not your child's favourite subject, something needs…
Read more
male_teacher_-_students
Governments in Australia are increasingly looking to “fast-track” professionals or…
Read more
Cry babies

Dry your eyes!
The newest additions are on their way from the Babies who cry real tears!

Shipping-containers-freight-wallpaper-preview

Latest Tech Used In Shipping Containers
Read how the shipping industry has revolutionised

Motherpedia cover-2

Win 1 set of a 4-book hardcover illustrated boxed set
Barbara Murray’s new 4-book Sound Stories is perfect for parents and educators and could assist with NAPLAN results

Motherpedia cover (4)

Where to celebrate Oktoberfest Australia
Get ready for this celebration!

Motherpedia cover-4

A Fortnight of Foodie Experiences at East Village
A taste of East Village. What's in it for me?

Globber my too fix up cover

We Try: Globber My TOO Fix Up
A scooter that grows with your child

Throw a winning cricket pitch

3 Steps to a Winning Backyard Cricket Pitch
Ex-Adelaide Oval legend curator Les Burdett shares his tips for getting your backyard cricket pitch test match ready this summer

A bike that follows your kids life cycle - motherpedia - cover

A Bike That Follows Your Kids Life Cycle
Check out the Bunzi 2-in-1 gradual balance bike!

Moonlight lifestyle

Moonlight Cinema to bring…
Moonlight Cinema announces brand new Western Sydney venue

Screen shot 2019-11-26 at 8.29.12 am

Your Magical Christmas Wonderland…
Adventure park is about to light up the night sky with its "Christmas Festival of Lights"

Screen shot 2019-11-21 at 11.11.36 am

The Preston Market Gets…
It's time to feel pumped up for the holiday season!

Bruno-kelzer-zqzuigxcvrq-unsplash

Bunnings team members get…
Help raise funds by buying a snag or donating at your local store.