The poll by movie website Fandango.com saw newlywed Matthew McConaughey edge out Brad Pitt for the top spot.
The Texan father-of-two, who wed fiancee Camila Alves last weekend, has claimed 21 per cent of the vote.
Johnny Depp came a close third, while Mark Wahlberg and Hemsworth rounded out the top five.
Following were Will Smith, Matt Damon, Denzel Washington, Jackman and Tom Cruise, who came in 10th with four per cent of the vote.
Father's Day in the US falls on Sunday.